Offshoring Indigenous Creative Opportunities.

Handwritten list of terms (Blackcladding, Blackwashing, Blackshelling, Whitewashing, Whiteballing) with 'Whitewashing' circled in red.

Over the past two weeks, we have received two concerning calls from prospective clients about two separate Indigenous creative agencies that are reportedly offshoring creative work overseas, including to India and Indonesia.

What makes this particularly concerning is that both agencies are reportedly Supply Nation certified and registered with their respective state Indigenous Chambers of Commerce.
 
We all know that “black cladding” continues to be an issue within the Indigenous business sector. In my view, this is unlikely to be properly addressed until there is a robust and transparent system of authentication that can verify Indigenous ownership, capability and genuine participation in the delivery of services.
 
However, the offshoring of Indigenous creative opportunities, or having Indigenous creative work undertaken by non-Indigenous people is another issue that deserves serious attention.
 
Having worked in the Indigenous creative, design and digital space for most of my career, I believe there is a responsibility that comes with operating an Indigenous creative business or any Indigenous business.
 
Establishing an Indigenous-owned business is one thing. Building the capability, skills, employment and economic opportunities within the Indigenous creative sector is another.
 
From what I understand, these two agencies were established by Indigenous people, which we can all agree is a positive thing. Indigenous entrepreneurship should absolutely be encouraged and supported by the all sectors, in particular by mob.
 
But if an Indigenous business is winning work specifically through the Indigenous business ecosystem, only to have that work undertaken by non-Indigenous contractors or, even worse, offshore because the business does not have the skills or capability to deliver it locally then I believe we need to ask some serious questions.
 

Where is the investment in developing Indigenous creative capability? Where is the opportunity for young Indigenous designers, creatives, developers and digital practitioners to gain experience and build their careers?

Since my days being training at Aboriginal Hostels Limited, I have worked in the Indigenous design and digital space and have always believed that one of the most important responsibilities of an Indigenous creative business is to create opportunities for other Indigenous creatives.
 
That means mentoring, training, employing, collaborating with and investing in the next generation.
 
This is precisely why we established Indigenous Design Labs and have invested our own time, money and resources (no government funding) for  six years into creating pathways for young Indigenous creatives. We don’t just talk about building Indigenous creative capability we actively work to develop it.

What does it actually mean to be an Indigenous creative agency if the creative work being commissioned is ultimately being produced by a non-Indigenous person or overseas?

There is nothing wrong with an Indigenous business growing, partnering with others or accessing specialist expertise when required. Collaboration is an important part of any successful creative industry. But this should be in Indigenous hands and we all know that their are capable black business that can do the work across the creative sectors from design, code and film.
 
But there is a significant difference between bringing in expertise to strengthen Indigenous capability and simply outsourcing Indigenous creative opportunities because the capability has not been developed locally.
 
 

If government agencies, corporations and procurement organisations are serious about supporting Indigenous businesses, then the conversation cannot stop at ownership.

We need to look at where the work is actually being done, who is doing it, where the money goes, and whether the engagement is contributing to the growth of Indigenous capability, employment and economic participation.
 
Otherwise, we risk creating a system where Indigenous businesses become a gateway to accessing Indigenous procurement opportunities, while the actual creative and economic benefits are being delivered by non-Indigenous people or exported overseas.
 
That isn’t building an Indigenous creative industry, it is simply moving the opportunity somewhere else and removing the opportunities for our own young creatives trying to get their break.
 
And after more than 25 years working in this space, I believe we should be asking whether that is really what Indigenous procurement was intended to achieve. For me it’s always been about creating sustainable opportunity, self-determination and wealth generation free from the shackles of Government funding.
 

For the great people in all sectors that are committed to uplifting sustainable economic opportunity and help build the 'Blak Business Economy' please make sure you invest time into looking a the business supply and creative chain before you commit any opportunities. We all want to grow a true 'Blak Economy' not simple 'Whitewash' what we are doing.

Offshoring Indigenous Creative Opportunities

Captain Cook’s back and he’s got a shiny new coat

AI and Indigenous Art & Design

Same Animal, different breed

Contact

We’d love to have a yarn about your next project!

0428 817 409